So this is the one and only time all year that all of us, or perhaps most of us at least, buy a pumpkin.
But how many of us would actually recognize the Great Pumpkin if we actually did see it?
1.Passion…Halloween should be as fun as possible for your entire family. Don’t be like the lady that we all hate on the movie The Grinch who gets out her tape measure and actually measures the pumkin before buying it.
Never forget that the holidays—not only Halloween, but also Thanksgiving and Christmas—are supposed to be fun, Be passionate about spending time with your family, not spending more money than your neighbors did on the orange globe sitting on your front porches.
2. Perfection…The pumpkin that you choose doesn’t have to be perfect. Choosing one with bumps and lumps have character.
3.Personal Preference…The perfect pumpkin is that one pumpkin that you or your child could never imagine leaving the PSL without—even though it isn’t the shape or size that everyone else is attracted to. Follow your heart, not the crowd.
4. Pigmentation…It is okay if your pumpkin is not a bright orange like the ones that you see on children’s movies and books.
Even though many will say, “the darker the color, the better the pumpkin,” use your common sense here…most of us can tell if a pumkin is the “ugly duckling” of the pumpkin patch.
Just make sure that the top of the pumpkin, specifically around the stem, is not dull, because this indicates frost damage.
5. Pitch…The pumpkin that you choose should have a deep, echoing sound when you pick it up, hold the pumpkin next to your ear, and knock on its side with your knuckles.
The louder the sound, the better the pumpkin.
6. Post…By “post” I simply mean the stem, but couldn’t come up with another synonym for the word “stem” that didn’t seem vulgar.
Anyway, the pumpkin that you choose should have a hard, dark green or black stem.
Squeeze the stem to test its firmness. If the stem is soft to the touch, it’s not an ideal pick.
The stem should not bend and break when you pick it up…that would be about like the trunk of the just-chosen Christmas tree snapping in two before you get out of the Christmas Tree lot.
7. Potholes…Gently press on the pumpkin with your finger to make sure that there aren’t any soft spots that indicate that the pumpkin has already started to decay and won’t last much longer.
The pumpkin should be firm all over.
Even though the pumpkin may look perfect from the outside, you do not want to start carving your pumpkin, only to find that it’s rotten.
8. Profile…Choose an oblong pumpkin, as opposed to a round one. Round or oval pumpkins are easier to carve, have more workspace, and a bigger cavity filled with more seeds.
Choose a pumpkin with a flat bottom that sits well.
9. Proportion…If you are going to be using your pumpkin for baking and cooking, avoid those big pumpkins that are typically sold to be carved into jack-o’-lanterns, regardless of how appealing they may seem.
Those bigger pumpkins are definitely not the best when it comes to cooking and baking. In fact, bigger pumpkins are typically very stringy, bland, and watery.
Instead look for pumpkins that weigh from four to eight pounds and that are labeled as “sugar pumpkins” or “pie pumpkins”—such as Baby Pam, Autumn Gold, Ghost Rider, New England Pie Pumpkin, Lumina , Cinderella, and Fairy Tale.
If only big carving pumpkins are available, choose a winter squash like butternut squash instead, if you will actually be cooking or baking with it.
10. Punctures and Pimples…Choose a pumpkin that has no scrapes, brown spots, bruises, cuts, or holes on its surface. Any of these “punctures and pimples” will make your pumpkin rot faster.
11.Purpose…Choose the thickness of the walls of your pumpkin according to what you will be using for. If you are going to be making a jack o’ lantern, choose a pumpkin with thin walls. If you are going to be cooking with it, choose a pumpkin with thicker walls.